A Wild lesson
After reading ... Review and Reflect

To Take or Not to Take?

Exploring a dilemma using Conscience Alley.

Lesson length: 1 session

Required reading: Pages 11-14

Text potential

  • Narrative features: Plot: dilemma

Strategies

Purpose

Narratives have points of conflict, decisions and dilemmas and writers invite readers to reflect on this critical points. Would things have turned out differently if x had done y? What would I have done if I was in X’s shoes?

Conscience Alley is a drama strategy that enables children to explore opposing points of view and consider the consequences of taking a particular course of action in the story. In this lesson, children will be challenged to think beyond the original text to explore alternative possibilities including moral and ethical considerations.

Teacher’s note. When the children are organised in groups encourage them to share their ideas directly with each other rather than speaking through you. To do this you will need to organise the children so the can see each other’s faces, a circle works well. Children are more likely to speak with each other if you sit slightly outside the circle and look down and appear to be making notes. Intervene only if the discussion falters or the children need support with speaking and listening protocols e.g. respectful listening).

To support deeper thinking it is usually best if the teacher adopts teacher-in-role initially and then gives the children the option to have a go afterwards.

Preparation

  • Copies of Wild, at least one between two.
  • If you have access to a large space such as a hall, this would be good but not essential as long as you can create space in your classroom.
  • On a large sheet of paper or whiteboard draw a T Diagram with 2 headings:
Leave the child in the wilderness.  Take the child to civilisation 
   
   

Process

Re-read the story with the children reading along in unison and following in their books (choral reading). By now the children should be very familiar with the text and reading fluently and expressively.

Write the word dilemma on the board and give a definition. ( a point where a difficult choice has to be made).

Ask:

Is there a point in the story where a character or characters have a dilemma (have to make a difficult choice).

If the children don’t mention it, say, I think the hunters have a dilemma when they see the wild girl in the forest.

  • Should the hunters leave the wild girl or take her? 

Supplementary prompts:

  • What if they leave her and she gets hurt?
  • Will the hunters be rewarded?
  • Are the hunters responsible for the child’s happiness?
  • Is the child theirs to take?
  • Who does she belong to?

Record the children’s responses on the T Diagram.

Organise the class into two groups. One half supports the first statement, ‘The hunters must leave the child’.  And the other half support the statement, ‘The hunters must take her to safety’. Explain, they do not have to agree with the statement they have been given but must give reasons supporting it.

If you have a supporting adult in the class, each work with a group to listen to the arguments. Only offer prompts if the discussion falters or you need to give advice with managing speaking and listening protocols e.g. how to take turns, respectful listening etc.

When they have had enough discussion time gather the class.

Form 2 lines facing each other. You or another adult in the class will be one of the hunters. As you walk slowly down the alley point to the children when you want to hear their opinion.

Ask for volunteers to be the hunters. They must walk through the alley while children from both sides whisper their thoughts about the statements. When you get to the end, say something along the lines:

‘I heard some very convincing arguments for leaving Wild in the forest. I was impressed by xxxx and xxxx. But I also heard some thoughtful reasons why Wild should be taken to the city. It’s heard to argue against xxxxxx and xxxxx. This has put in me in a dilemma. it’s a very difficult to choice to make. However, I think I should xxxxxx because xxxx. Thank you to all of you for your advice.

Explain that different hunters might reach different conclusions. Would anyone like to be a hunter and walk through the alley.

Ask the hunters to reflect on the experience. 

  • What points of view stood out? 
  • What reasons did you hear? 
  • Which views made sense to you?
  • Have you been persuaded what to do?

Final reflection

Challenge the children to retell the story with the alternative option where the hunters leave her in the wilderness. 

  • Which would make the more interesting story?

Vocabulary

Key vocabulary

dilemma

 
Subject-specific and technical vocabulary 
Academic process words 
Morphological investigation 
Etymological investigation 
Idioms