During reading ... Digging Deeper

How to be concise and precise

Learning ways to be concise when writing instructions.

Lesson length: 1 hour 0 minutes / 1 session

Required reading: 26 and 27

Text potential

  • Inference opportunities: Author intentions
  • Genre: Information Text
  • Text Features: instruction
  • Language features: Parenthesis
  • Language features: Punctuation: inverted commas
  • Language features: Syntax: fronted adverbials

Purpose

Good instructional writing is concise and precise, enabling the reader to follow the instructions whilst doing something practical. Using imperative verbs, parenthesis, and short sentences allows the writer to use fewer words to describe the actions that need to be followed. This lesson explores how the writer successfully uses these conventions.

Preparation

  • Copies of I Ate Sunshine For Breakfast at least one between two
  • Have the equipment necessary for the children to complete the DIY task on pages 26 and 27

Process

Teacher’s note: Depending on your class and your preference, you could change the order of this lesson and get the children to follow the instructions and make their wild weed gardens first before you unpick how these instructions have been made concise.

You will have already read the first paragraph in the lesson ‘Now That’s a Peculiar Word’, but read the title and the first paragraph again and ask the children what we can make if we follow these instructions. Once they are clear, explain that you will follow the instructions and create wild weed gardens with a partner.

Before you create your wild weed garden, you will read through the instructions to check you have everything you need. Ask the children to read the ‘What You Will Need’ list with their partners. When they have read them, explain that Michael Holland has added information in parenthesis for each item. Read each item and ask the children to explain what they mean. As you discuss this with the children, demonstrate how he has used just a few words to be specific about what is needed. He doesn’t need to explain his reasons because he embeds information in the parenthesis. For example, he doesn’t write. 

‘You will need to find a large clear plastic bottle. This will need to be at least 2 litres, or you will not fit the soil into it, but you could have a larger bottle if you like. When you have found your bottle, you will need to remove the label. You can do this by soaking the bottle in warm water first as this will dissolve the glue so that you can pull the label off,’

We know that the information in the parenthesis is additional information about the bottle and only uses words he needs to make sense because he does not have to write in complete sentences. This means the information is concise (giving information clearly in a few words).

Now, look at ‘How to Make Your Bottle Garden’ and ask the children to read step 1 with their partner. And ask them to discuss how Holland has kept this paragraph concise.

Points to raise:

  • Use of fronted adverbials 1) making sure there aren’t any animals in the soil you have 2) If dry
  • These enable him to get straight to the point rather than If you find some animals in the soil… or If your soil is dry, you will need…
  • Compound expression quarter-fill rather than fill your bottle with the soil until it is a quarter full.

Now, look at Step 2 for ways Holland has been concise.

 Points to raise:

  • Imperative verbs
  • Use of ellipsis to show that you have to wait for quite a long time rather than explaining that you need to wait for days or weeks

Now, look at Step 3.

Points to raise:

  • Notice that the making is now done, and this step describes what to observe
  • The short sentence ‘Be patient.’
  • Ask the children why he used quotation marks around ’empty’. This links to the learning in the ‘Now that’s a Peculiar Word’ lesson. The soil is unlikely to be empty; therefore, this is ironic.

Now look at Step 4 and ask if this is an instruction or a suggestion. What word/words made you think this?

Now provide the resources for creating their wild weed bottle gardens. Make sure the labels are still on the bottles and leave the equipment on a table so that the pairs have to work out what they need and figure out how to remove animals or create a funnel from paper.

Final reflection

  • What strategies have you learnt for writing concisely?
  • When you followed the instructions, did you follow the order or could you do any of the steps simultaneously?
  • Are these instructions concise and precise (accurate and detailed)?

Vocabulary

Key vocabulary

concise, precise, ironic, instruction

 
Subject-specific and technical vocabulary

fronted adverbial, parenthesis, sentence, compound expression

 
Academic process words 
Morphological investigation 
Etymological investigation 
Idioms 

Contributors

Jo Castro

Jo has worked in education for over 20 years. For much of that
time, she worked in East London as a teacher and assistant head.
She has always been passionate about reading and has been involved
in developing Take One Book teaching sequences and in devising
and writing Just Imagine training materials.
She is a qualified coach and works with leaders in education as
well as teachers and teaching assistants. She is particularly interested
in helping educators develop a coaching approach with learners in
the classroom.